The Best Custom Shutters, Blinds & Shades!
Proudly Serving Indy, Carmel and Central Indiana

Blinds vs Shutters

When it comes to blinds and shutters, which window treatment is the perfect solution for your Indianapolis home? There’s only one way to find out: compare them!

Blinds are a traditional window treatment that have been covering windows in Indianapolis for as long as sliced bread has been around. And shutters are an in-vogue window treatment that has exploded in popularity in the past 20 years. Let’s take a look at how these two window treatment veterans go up against each other when it comes to durability, energy efficiency, cleaning, special window shapes, and home resale value.



Blinds are available in metal, hardwood, faux wood, and vertical styles. With 300+ colors and textures to choose from, blinds let you match your window treatments to your style –right down to the pattern.

Plantation shutters are available in Polywood® and Ovation® wood. We supply Polywood in three premium white paint colors – and a custom paint color program for hues of beige, yellow, and grey. Ovation wood shutters come in 28 wood stains and 11 paint colors.


When attended to, blinds last an average of 5 years. While shutters can last more than 50 years. 

Energy Efficiency

When closed, the thin slats on blinds can’t block much of the airflow and heat from outside. But shutters, with their thick louvers and tailored mounting, seal off the influence of the external climate. In fact, Polywood plantation shutters insulate up to 70% better than similar traditional wood shutters – and 1600% better than aluminum blinds!


Dusting the thin slats of blinds can be a hassle – especially with the cords that run through from top to bottom. When plantation shutters are set up with a hidden or rear-mount tilt rod, all you have to do to clean the large louvers is tilt them back with your hand and wipe the louvers, unhindered.

Special Window Shapes

Traditional blinds can only be mounted on rectangular-shaped windows, not arched, circular, octagonal, or triangular windows. And blinds would only obscure the beautiful window you fell in love with when you purchased the house, anyway. Shutters, conversely, can be custom-made to fit your windows exactly, regardless of their shape, letting you have access to the view and control over privacy – while complementing your specialty-shaped windows’ beauty.

Home Resale Value

When your home is assessed for resale, all the permanent fixtures are examined. Blinds can be moved from one house to another, but shutters are custom-built and become part of your windows and home. As a matter of fact, they add value to your home not only by being a permanent asset, but also by being an energy-efficient one!

We highlighted the differences between blinds and shutters in this table for you. Picking between the two window treatments is based on your style, your windows, and your budget. 





Metal, Hardwood, Faux Wood, Vertical

Polywood and Ovation Wood


Last about 5 years

Last 50+ years

Energy Efficiency






Special Window Shapes


Customizable to fit any window shape

Home Resale Value

No effect

Increases home resale value

Between Blinds and Shutters, Which Is the Perfect Solution for You?

It comes down to personal preference. And, when you’ve decided, we’ll be here to walk you through the process of designing them for your windows. Call us at 317-558-9066 or fill out the form below to schedule your free in-home consultation today!